By now, you've heard about the murder of Trayvon Martin, unless of course you've just been living under a rock, or going through you're own incredible struggles like being homeless or living in a war torn country. But just in case you haven't heard , Anti-racist educator Tim Wise has the best explanation that I've seen yet on the internet
here. He also has the best historical explanation, I feel, of the outrage in support of Martin's shooter, Zimmerman
here.
There are all types of debates going on about whether or not Zimmerman had a right to shoot Martin and all the factors that would determine an answer to that question. My biggest issue with the discourse, in the media and in everyday conversation, is that the conversation is centered around intent in the first place. Two particular discourses around intent really bother me: whether or not it was a raced-based issue and whether or not Zimmerman or Martin had the better character.
Now as to the first discourse: I am not going to argue about if this was a raced based issue. I think there is plenty of evidence out there, as pointed out by the two Wise articles, that it was based on race. I think that the 911 tape of Zimmerman calling Martin a "fucking coon" (although to be fair, the word coon is kind of hard to hear on the tape), is proof. I even think studies like this
NBC experiment on how we react to different races committing a blatant crime, is evidence that even if Zimmerman didn't have conscious thoughts about going after Martin because he was black, it's in our subconscious to view black men as criminals (no matter what race we ourselves are, since there's claim that Zimmerman is Hispanic, which I won't even get into).
Now as for the second discourse: There initially was a lot of discussion attacking Zimmerman's character by calling him crazy and paranoid (because of the multiple upon multiple phone calls he made to the police on a regular basis and based upon his neighbors' reports of his behavior). Because of that discussion there has as of late been talk that Zimmerman was actually an amazing guy with a high regard for the law (despite his blatant disregard for the orders of the 911 dispatcher to stay in his vehicle) which is why he was a neighborhood WATCH (keyword WATCH) man in the first play. There is also talk that, actually Martin wasn't so innocent because he was suspended from school for marijuana possession (suspected), because of some twitter posts, and because of some facebook photos that show him being a "gangsta".
All of this is meaningless to the indisputable fact that Zimmerman shoot Martin. Whether Zimmerman shot him because he was Black and whether or not Martin was a good person means absolutely nothing to that fact. The only argument that has any merit at all in the discussion is whether or not it was self-defense, but even considering that Zimmerman still shot Martin. And at the very least he should be brought up on manslaughter, even if he is plead out.
The race debate is relevant to greater society. If his intent was race based (and I believe it was) I think that it and the discourse surrounding this case is evidence that we are not a post-racial society and that American society as a whole has a problem with viewing black men as criminals, a problem that can have dire consequences.
But that debate and the debate over character especially, has no relevancy over whether or not Martin deserved to die. He didn't. He did nothing wrong besides walk in the "wrong neighborhood". He had no weapon (unless you consider skittles and ice tea weapons). And even if he attacked Zimmerman, Zimmerman was the one in pursuit to begin with. But I don't want to even get into the self-defense argument because regardless of that fact, an innocent boy still lost his life.
Innocent not because he had never done anything wrong in his life, innocent because he wasn't doing anything wrong at that moment. Innocent because he was not expecting to be gunned down in a "safe" neighborhood, coming back from the store. Innocent because his future was stolen from him in one of the worst ways. And now his character is trying to be stolen from him instead of justice given to him. And that has to be one of the worst crimes of all....